Compare FDM with other 3D printing routes
Compare FDM, MJF and SLA based on load, surface detail and build size. Set what the sample must verify before committing to the process.
Build functional housings, fixtures and large parts with engineering thermoplastic filament. Match layer direction and wall structure to the real load.
Send CAD, drawings, quantity and load direction. KeepWin reviews the filament, build orientation, infill and any secondary machining with its production partners.
Add a process, assembly or inspection requirement to the engineering brief.
Compare FDM, MJF and SLA based on load, surface detail and build size. Set what the sample must verify before committing to the process.
Consider SLA or DLP when fine detail or a smooth visual surface drives the design. Validate any loaded fit using the chosen resin and cure state.
Evaluate ABS-ESD7 for electronics trays or fixtures. Agree the surface resistance method, finished state and packaging if ESD control is required.
Check the envelope for the chosen filament and the intended orientation. For segmented parts, agree the seam, locating features and overall final dimensions.
Allow stock around selected bores and datums before printing. Agree how to clamp, ream and inspect features against the drawing.
Choose a compatible support and removal method. Confirm access for inserts, sanding or coating and check the final mating surfaces.
Open a topic to see what to include in the drawing and validation plan.
Layer bonding and deposited paths influence mechanical behavior. A feature loaded across layers may respond differently from one loaded along them. Identify pulling, bending, fastening and repeated-use loads so orientation can be reviewed around the actual job.
An orientation that gives an attractive visible face may not be best for a thin loaded tab. Review the tradeoff between strength direction, support contact, build time and dimensional control. Do not treat a nominally solid print as automatically isotropic.
Shells, top and bottom layers, infill and local reinforcement can change stiffness, mass and how a screw or insert is supported. Two prints made from the same outer CAD shape can have very different internal construction.
State whether the part is a visual model, a fixture or a load-bearing trial. For critical fasteners and contact areas, discuss local structure and any secondary installation. A high infill percentage alone does not define the wall geometry, layer bonding or final functional performance.
Overhangs and bridges may require support or a change of orientation. Breakaway and soluble support routes have different removal requirements. Enclosed supports can become difficult to remove, while supported surfaces may need cleanup.
Small holes, thin walls, embossed details and close fits must be reviewed against nozzle path, layer strategy and material behavior. Layer height is not a universal dimensional tolerance. If a hole is to be drilled or reamed afterward, include that operation and the associated allowance in the scope.
Common filament families have different stiffness, heat response, moisture sensitivity and chemical behavior. Reinforced materials also require a suitable process and do not automatically solve every weak direction. Confirm the exact grade rather than selecting only a familiar polymer abbreviation.
Explain operating temperature, load duration, UV or chemical exposure and any contact requirements. A material approved for a specific use in another product does not automatically qualify the printed component. Storage, drying and manufacturing controls should suit the nominated material.
Support removal, sanding, coating, joining and insert installation can affect dimensions and appearance. Mark surfaces to leave as-printed and those requiring further work. Check assembly and function after the operations that matter to the finished part.
KeepWin coordinates the model, drawing, material, quantity and proposed build route with partners. Preserve the approved orientation, internal construction and finishing decisions for repeat orders. Compare quotations on the delivered condition, not only the time spent depositing filament.
Compare confirmed process ranges. Use the test data below to review how the same filament behaves in XZ and ZX.
| Engineering criterion | FDM | MJF | SLA |
|---|---|---|---|
| Build envelope | 914 × 610 × 914 mm | 380 × 284 × 380 mm | 800 × 800 × 550 mm · 1,500 × 750 × 550 mm |
| As-built linear tolerance | ±0.20 mm (≤100 mm) / ±0.20% | ±0.20 mm (≤100 mm) / ±0.25% | ±0.10 mm (≤100 mm) / ±0.15% |
| Selected features after machining | ±0.05 mm | ±0.05 mm | ±0.03–0.05 mm |
| Layer thickness | 0.127–0.254 mm | 0.08 mm | 0.05–0.10 mm |
| Wall, through hole and cleaning channel | 1.0–1.2 mm · Ø1.5–2.0 mm · 1.2–1.5 mm | 0.8–1.0 mm · Ø1.2–1.5 mm · 1.0–1.2 mm | 0.8–1.0 mm · Ø0.8–1.0 mm · 0.6–0.8 mm |
| What to verify before approval | Match the main load to layer direction and validate the finished fit. | Check the grade, powder access and load orientation. | Critical dimensions after cure and properties in the agreed test state. |
FDM one-piece size depends on grade, platform and orientation. MJF commonly recommends 350 × 260 × 350 mm per part. Larger SLA configurations and all secondary features are reviewed by drawing.
| Item | Capability and conditions |
|---|---|
| Materials by process | ABS-M30 / ABS-ESD7 · ASA · PC / PC-ABS · Nylon 12CF · ULTEM 9085 / 1010 · Victrex AM 200 FIL (PAEK) |
| One-piece build envelope | 914 × 610 × 914 mm |
| Layer thickness | 0.127–0.254 mm |
| Typical as-built linear tolerance | ±0.20 mm (≤100 mm) / ±0.20% |
| Selected features after secondary work | ±0.05 mm |
| Minimum wall, through hole and channel | 1.0–1.2 mm · Ø1.5–2.0 mm · 1.2–1.5 mm |
Check polymer, layup and climate requirements with the selected chamber. Tight fit targets require compatible inserts or secondary work.
| Item | Capability and conditions |
|---|---|
| Build direction review | Keep critical cosmetic faces away from supports where possible. Review hole orientation and XY/Z properties for loaded clips. |
| Heat, ageing and witness coupons | HDT 0.45 / 1.82 MPa · 85 °C / 85% RH · QUV · ASTM D638 / D790 |
Compare load along and across layers in the supplier’s specimen orientations. Confirm the critical loading direction on the actual part.
| Filament grades | Tensile stress at break · XZ | Tensile stress at break · ZX | Elongation at break · XZ / ZX |
|---|---|---|---|
| ABS-M30 | 28.1 MPa | 26.8 MPa | 8.1% / 1.8% |
| Nylon 12CF | 83.5 MPa | 32.7 MPa | 2.4% / 1.2% |
| ULTEM 9085 | 67.8 MPa | 38.9 MPa | 5.7% / 2.5% |
ASTM D638 supplier data on F900 test specimens. ABS-M30 used T16, Nylon 12CF used T20C, and natural ULTEM 9085 used T20. Confirm the build and test state for acceptance.
Choose individual filament grades for the brief. Each comparison checkbox uses the representative grade named on that card.
Use ABS-M30 for general housings or jigs, ABS-ESD7 when static dissipation is specified, and ASA when outdoor UV exposure matters.
Manufacturer data sheets · ABS-M30 ↗Evaluate PC or the PC-ABS blend for loaded housings and fixtures. Check each grade’s toughness, heat response and finished dimensions for the part.
Manufacturer data sheets · PC-ABS ↗PA12 with 35% chopped carbon fiber by weight. Consider it for lightweight fixtures and end-of-arm tooling after reviewing the across-layer load.
Manufacturer data sheets · Nylon 12CF ↗ULTEM 9085 and 1010 are separate PEI grades. Victrex AM 200 FIL is a low-melting PAEK. Review each on a compatible platform for temperature, load and any required flammability evidence.
Manufacturer data sheets · ULTEM 9085 ↗Manufacturer data sheets · Victrex AM 200 FIL ↗Select a representative grade above or compare all four to see the property table.
| Engineering criterion | ABS-M30 | PC-ABS | Nylon 12CF | ULTEM 9085 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Flexural modulus · XZ / ZX (ASTM D790) | 2.22 / 1.96 GPa | 1.86 / 1.68 GPa | 11.1 / 2.34 GPa | 2.39 / 1.93 GPa |
| HDT at 1.82 MPa (ASTM D648) | 99.9 °C | 112.0 °C | 153.7 °C | 172.9 °C |
| Examples of compatible supports | SR-30 / SR-35 | SR-110 | SR-110 | SUP8500B |
| Selection priority | General-purpose fixtures with routine assembly loads | Evaluate the balance of toughness and heat response | High stiffness when the main load follows the layers | Elevated temperature with verified grade and build state |
The figures apply to the named grades. The flexural values are from F900 specimens, with PC-ABS on T16. HDT is a test under a defined load. Confirm service temperature and exposure on the finished part.
Specify another listed filament in the inquiry. Confirm the exact grade, platform, support and part size during review.
Agree the release condition for each stage before committing to repeat batches.
Mark load paths, cosmetic faces and critical fits.
Dry as specified for the grade. Record walls, infill and supports.
Apply the grade-specific nozzle, bed and chamber settings.
Clean or break away the supports. Install inserts or ream holes as agreed.
Verify final fits and any agreed optical, load or ESD checks.
Protect finished parts and archive the approved filament lot and build definition.
Select the records you need. Confirm their format, test methods and availability for the selected resin and process.
Identify the filament supplier, grade and lot for the approved build.
Agree which features to record and which drawing revision governs release.
Record the specified finished bores, datums and the measurement method.
Agree which build settings to record for repeat orders, including orientation and wall structure.
Specify the applicable test, grade, wall thickness and evidence required for the part.
Attach selected routes, filament candidates and quality records to your CAD inquiry. Mark load direction, critical fits and finishing requirements on the drawing.
Process routes · DFM guide · Materials · Inspection and delivery
Select a process, design topic, filament or quality record above, or add a note.
No. Layer interfaces, deposited paths, local voids and material processing can still affect behavior. Validate the part for its intended load.
No. They are a normal feature of extrusion printing. Define acceptable appearance and any finishing rather than expecting a molded surface by default.
Yes, where appropriate. Joint geometry, alignment, fastening or bonding and final inspection must be included in the design.